Cautionary tale - beware of experts

From: Dillon, Dillon, & Kuh (mavericks@No-Spam)
Date: Mon Dec 31 2001 - 00:19:30 MST

  • Next message: Robert Leyland: "Re: Observing Report 12/15/01 - Dinosaur Point"

    Just a lighthearted yarn here. Jo gave me Parallax for Christmas, a
    biographically based book of the whole history of getting to measure
    stellar distances, from Hipparchus and Aristarchus on. Well researched,
    very well written. Paul LeFevre had raved about it here on TAC a while back.

    Hirschberg, the author, is an astronomer at U Mass Dartmouth, got all kinds
    of credentials as a bonafide pro. On pg 20 he's describing the motions of
    the planets against the background stars, saying they move to the west and
    retrograde to the east. Here I am reading this at bedtime Friday night.
    Fell asleep going _"Huh?"_.

    Once again we can take note of how all the king's experts and all the
    king's editors can't substitute for actual observation. 3.5 years ago it
    was a different universe for me. Now I know when I started taking note of
    where Jupiter and Saturn were, they were in Aries; now Saturn's definitely
    in Taurus and Jupiter's all the way to Gemini, certainly moving eastbound.
    Last spring I watched Mars retrograde across Scorpius, heading east. Now
    it's way over in Aquarius.

    I fell asleep going over this as a comforting litany.

    Thankful for the actual sky, wherever it is.
    Yours truly,
    DDK

    Happy Clearskied New Year!

    Jamie Dillon <mavericks@No-Spam> <*> http://www.winepress.com/jd1.htm
    "Security is mostly a superstition. It does not exist in nature nor do the
    children of men as a whole experience it. Avoiding danger is no safer in
    the long run than outright exposure. Life is either a daring adventure or
    nothing." - Helen Keller



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Mon Dec 31 2001 - 00:21:03 MST


    The Astronomy Connection -- Mailing List Archives